American journalist and novelist Michael Scott Moore says an inward practice of forgiveness helped him endure 977 days of captivity after he was kidnapped in Somalia. In a first-person essay, Moore reflects on whether he could forgive the men who held him, and how new information about one captor changed his understanding of the experience.
Moore was abducted near Galkayo on January 21, 2012, while researching piracy. He was released in September 2014, after a captivity that the U.S. Department of Justice and Moore’s publisher, the Pulitzer Center, describe as lasting 977 days.
Mercy as a way to endure
Moore writes that forgiveness helped him preserve his sense of self while he was held. He rejects the idea that this response meant he had become aligned with his captors, describing it instead as a private practice that helped him withstand the ordeal. These are Moore’s own reflections, not a clinical assessment of his experience.
His account does not present forgiveness as a simple resolution. Moore says that, for a time, he regarded Mohamed Tahlil Mohamed as a comparatively gentle guard. That view shifted after Moore learned from the U.S. trial record that Tahlil had held a senior security role in the pirate operation and controlled weapons.
Moore writes that the information weakened his impulse to forgive Tahlil, even as his desire for revenge remained diminished. The tension between those feelings forms the central question of his essay: what forgiveness can mean when a captive’s understanding of a captor changes after release.
A captivity that extended to sea
Moore’s ordeal moved beyond land captivity. The Justice Department’s account of the trial says he was transferred in April 2012 to the hijacked fishing vessel Naham III, where he was held with the ship’s crew.
Moore’s essay places his experience alongside the crew members’ prolonged captivity. He writes that 26 crew members were released in 2016 after nearly five years as hostages, while two died in captivity. Their experience shows that the episode involved more than the kidnapping of one journalist, extending to seafarers held for years.
Convictions and sentences
A federal jury convicted Tahlil and Abdi Yusuf Hassan in February 2023. The Justice Department said Hassan, a Galmudug security official, helped lead ransom-extortion efforts, while Tahlil, a Somali army officer, supervised guards and served as the pirates’ head of security and armorer.
On November 12, 2024, both men were sentenced to 30 years in prison for hostage-taking, terrorism and firearms offenses. Those convictions and sentences provide a legal record against which Moore revisits his personal response to his captors, while his reflections on mercy remain his own interpretation of what helped him survive.
Accounts of ransom details differ. A contemporaneous Reuters report quoted a regional official who said he did not know of a ransom payment, while Moore’s later account says money was sent to Somalia. The accounts also give differing totals, so the available evidence does not establish a definitive amount.
