An investigation by Unearthed and Public Eye found that 1,605 of 2,857 Brazilian health-ministry poisoning reports from 2025 that named an identifiable agricultural product listed brands sold by European pesticide companies. The findings concern reports naming products, not a confirmed count of illnesses caused by those products.
The distinction is central to interpreting the figures. Brazil’s reporting system includes suspected pesticide poisonings, and clinicians assess whether cases are recorded as confirmed poisonings or exposures. The investigation’s tally therefore describes entries in official records, not independently established causation in every case.
What the investigation counted
The figures were reported by The Guardian on November 17, 2026, following an analysis by Unearthed and Public Eye. Public Eye announced the investigation the previous day. The two accounts are parts of the same investigation, rather than independent confirmations of its results.
The analysis focused on records that identified an agricultural product. It found that 1,605 of 2,857 such reports named brands sold by European pesticide companies. That scope matters: the figure is not the total number of pesticide-related reports in Brazil, nor does it mean that every report involved a confirmed poisoning.
The headline description “European-made pesticides” would go beyond what the findings establish. The reported analysis identifies brands sold by European pesticide companies; the available evidence does not show that all the products were manufactured in Europe.
The Guardian also reported that about a third of the cases in the investigation involved chemicals not permitted for use on EU farms. That is a finding attributed to the investigation, and it should not be read as establishing that every such chemical was illegally exported. European Union rules require export notifications for certain chemicals banned or severely restricted in the EU, but the regulation does not impose a blanket export ban on every pesticide barred from EU use. Requirements depend on the substance and circumstances.
Reports are not the same as confirmed causation
Brazilian clinicians submit suspected pesticide-poisoning cases to the national reporting system. According to the investigation, a clinician’s assessment determines whether a report is classified as a confirmed poisoning or as exposure. Laboratory confirmation is rare, the report said. A product identified in a record is therefore not, by itself, proof that it caused the symptoms.
The investigation identified 32 deaths among reports it linked to European-company products. It said 31 were classified as confirmed poisonings and 26 as suicides. These figures are findings from the investigation, rather than counts independently verified by the other supplied sources.
The reporting system provides a wider context, but its figures cover a different population and period. Brazil’s Health Ministry says its SINAN system collects and analyzes notifications of diseases and other conditions that public-health authorities are required to monitor. A ministry technical note records 63,053 notifications of pesticide-related exogenous intoxication over the preceding five years. That broader total should not be combined with or mistaken for the investigation’s 2025 subset of reports identifying a product.
Company disputes and regulatory context
Syngenta disputed aspects of the investigation’s interpretation. The Guardian reported that the company said nearly half the cases attributed to its products were not classified as confirmed intoxications. Syngenta also challenged product identifications based on descriptions it considered ambiguous or misspelled.
The company cited Brazil’s regulatory system and said it trained 95,000 people in Brazil in safe product use during 2025, according to The Guardian. Those statements provide the company’s response; the material supplied does not independently verify its objections or resolve the disputed identifications.
The evidence supports a careful distinction between domestic restrictions and international trade. EU rules address export notifications for specified chemicals under particular conditions. Whether a specific pesticide could lawfully be exported requires information about the substance and the applicable circumstances; the available material does not establish the export status of each chemical in the Brazilian reports.
The investigation raises questions about pesticide exposure and the presence of products linked to European firms in Brazilian health records. Its headline figure is meaningful as a count of identifiable-product reports, but the reporting system’s limits, company objections and lack of independent corroboration for the investigation’s totals all constrain what can be concluded from it.
