The International Court of Justice is due to deliver its judgment in The Gambia’s case against Myanmar on 19 November, as concerns about possible US pressure on the court’s judges draw attention to the distinction between criticism and confirmed sanctions. The evidence reviewed documents US Ambassador to the United Nations Mike Waltz’s criticism of ad hoc judge Navi Pillay, but does not establish that Washington has announced or imposed sanctions on ICJ judges.
The court’s 3 November announcement set the judgment for 10 a.m. local time at the Peace Palace in The Hague. The case concerns alleged violations of the Genocide Convention against the Rohingya. The ICJ has not yet ruled on the merits.
What is known about the sanctions concern
A November briefing by the UK House of Commons Library records Waltz’s criticism of Pillay and his reference to US actions against the International Criminal Court, or ICC. It does not report an announced US decision to sanction judges of the separate International Court of Justice, or ICJ. The available evidence supports describing concern about possible pressure, not a confirmed plan or sanctions already imposed on ICJ judges.
The distinction matters because the two courts are independent institutions. Reuters reported in October that the United States had announced sanctions aimed at the ICC. That report does not establish that Pillay, who previously worked for the ICC, or any other ICJ judge was sanctioned.
The Commons Library briefing says Waltz accused Pillay of trying to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide. That is his allegation, not an established account of her position. The briefing also says there is no public record of her approach in the proceedings, because judicial deliberations are confidential. The available material therefore does not support an inference about how she will vote.
A case brought by The Gambia
The Gambia filed its case on 11 November 2019, alleging that acts against the Rohingya violated the Genocide Convention. Myanmar denies genocide and has described its 2017 offensive as a counter-terrorism campaign, according to Reuters. The dispute before the ICJ concerns the responsibility of a state under the convention, rather than the criminal prosecution of individual officials.
The legal question includes whether the alleged acts were carried out with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected group. Reuters describes that intent as a requirement for proving genocide. The court has not yet determined whether the allegations meet that standard, and the judgment expected on 19 November will address the merits of the case.
The proceedings have unfolded over several years. The UN Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar says the ICJ ordered provisional measures in January 2020 and rejected Myanmar’s preliminary objections in 2022. The court held hearings on the merits from 12 to 29 January 2026 and began deliberations on 29 January.
Why the judgment may matter beyond the case
The judgment could inform the ICJ’s consideration of other cases involving the Genocide Convention. Reuters has reported that it may influence the court’s handling of South Africa’s case concerning Israel and Gaza. That is a possible legal significance, not a prediction of the outcome there or a determination that the judgment will control a separate case.
For now, the immediate issue is the court’s forthcoming decision in The Gambia’s case and the limits of what is known about US action. The supplied evidence records criticism of Pillay and a reference to sanctions against the ICC, while stopping short of verifying sanctions against ICJ judges. The court’s findings on Myanmar’s responsibility also remain pending.
