A consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian after a review of 45 cases found that 19 patients’ deaths were avoidable and linked to surgical issues. The findings were discussed in the Scottish Parliament on 19 November 2026, but the available reporting does not establish that police have opened a new investigation in response to the call.
What the review examined
Dr Mohammed Habib called for an investigation into the health board. The 19 deaths refer to cases assessed in an external review in 2022, not deaths newly identified in November 2026. Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra described the review in Holyrood as covering 45 cases and judging 19 deaths avoidable and due to surgical issues.
The review was conducted by two external professors, according to reporting by The Guardian. That report said they found an “extremely high” death rate in Aberdeen’s liver and pancreatic surgery, with rates reaching 18% for 2017 to 2020, compared with a stated national range of 2% to 3%.
The exact scope and interpretation of those figures remain unclear from the material available. Local reporting described the review as covering deaths between 2015 and 2021, while the full expert report was not located in the sources reviewed. Its methods and denominators therefore could not be checked against the original document.
Claims and responses
Habib has alleged that he raised safety concerns repeatedly from 2021 onward and that senior NHS Grampian officials did not act quickly enough. He and his solicitor have also argued that more patients may have died unnecessarily. Those claims have not been presented in the available evidence as findings of criminal liability.
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said a thorough investigation had taken place, that some work remained ongoing and that new evidence would be considered through clinical, governance and legal processes. The Scottish Government said it was for Police Scotland to decide whether to conduct a criminal investigation.
The status of police activity needs to be distinguished from Habib’s current request. The Guardian reported that Police Scotland had been approached for comment, but did not establish whether the force had opened an investigation in response. A separate report said Habib had previously been interviewed several times by Police Scotland’s Major Investigations Team and had received no update since November 2025. The scope and current status of any police inquiry remain unverified.
Service changes and oversight
The liver and pancreatic surgery department at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary was shut in March 2026, according to The Guardian. The report said an external expert had concluded that persistently high mortality in complex surgery indicated systemic failure.
Separately, the Scottish Government announced on 17 November 2026 that an external intervention team would support and oversee NHS Grampian following a Healthcare Improvement Scotland review. The government said Healthcare Improvement Scotland would review progress within three months. That announcement describes current oversight, but does not independently verify the specific findings about the 19 deaths.
The issue is part of wider scrutiny of NHS Grampian’s leadership and clinical governance. The Guardian reported that Scotland’s first minister called Habib’s disclosures gravely concerning, while rejecting calls for a criminal investigation in Holyrood on 19 November. Whether police or another independent authority will take further action remains unresolved in the evidence available.
