Three French officers convicted in racist assault on music producer

A Paris court found three officers guilty of violence against Michel Zecler in 2020, treating racism as an aggravating circumstance. Each received a five-year sentence, with part suspended.

Three French police officers were found guilty of intentionally assaulting music producer Michel Zecler, with racism treated as an aggravating circumstance, in a verdict reported on November 20. The Paris case concerned an attack outside Zecler’s studio in 2020.

The court also convicted all three officers of group violence and of falsifying an official report that accused Zecler of attacking them. The court accepted that one officer, Aurélien Lapersonne, had used a racist slur, and applied the racist aggravating factor to all three defendants.

Assault recorded outside studio

The incident took place on November 21, 2020, when officers stopped Zecler outside his music studio over an alleged failure to wear a face mask required under COVID-era rules. They pushed him into the studio entrance and beat him, according to reports of the case. Security-camera footage captured the assault.

In reaching its verdict, the court relied on Zecler’s consistent account and testimony from witnesses, Le Monde reported. The falsified police report, which alleged that Zecler had attacked the officers, also undermined their denials, according to AFP’s account of the ruling.

Sentences include suspended terms

Each officer received a five-year sentence, but the portions suspended differed. Lapersonne’s sentence included three years suspended, leaving two years to serve. Philippe Tondeux had three and a half years suspended, leaving 18 months, while Pierre Plantier had four years suspended, leaving one year.

Plantier’s remaining year may be served under electronic monitoring, AFP reported. Lapersonne and Tondeux were to be imprisoned later. All three officers were permanently barred from serving as police officers, according to reports of the verdict.

The sentences fell short of the four-to-six-year terms sought by prosecutors, Le Monde reported. Zecler’s lawyer said the sentences were insufficient, while describing the court’s recognition of racism as a possible precedent. That characterization was the lawyer’s assessment, not a determination that the ruling binds future courts.

AFP described guilty verdicts in alleged police-brutality cases as rare. The case’s recorded footage, findings on the officers’ report and explicit recognition of racism formed central parts of the proceedings and verdict.

The Beacon Briefing

Stay informed. See further.

The stories that matter, the context behind them. Get Beacon’s essential reporting in your inbox.

Placeholder signup form · Connect your newsletter provider to activate.