The Justice Department’s suspension of a one-year legal-experience requirement has opened assistant U.S. attorney positions to recent law graduates, including lawyers who passed a bar exam within the past year. ProPublica reported that it identified more than 50 newly hired prosecutors with fewer than three years of experience, but said its count was likely incomplete and was not an official department-wide tally.
One example in the investigation is Preston Bigley, who graduated from Texas A&M’s law school in May and was hired in August as an incoming assistant U.S. attorney, pending bar admission. After passing the bar, he announced he would serve in the Western District of Texas. His path illustrates the shift, but the reporting does not suggest every new hire had only just become licensed.
A changed threshold for hiring
A Justice Department message dated March 13 suspended the one-year experience requirement for attorney vacancy announcements through February 28, 2027, according to Bloomberg Law. The department cited an exigent hiring need. Bloomberg reported that the change appeared in job postings and was confirmed by two people familiar with the matter.
The Associated Press separately reported the suspension and said the department had acknowledged losing nearly 1,000 assistant U.S. attorneys. The available reporting links the policy change to a hiring need, but does not establish that every vacancy arose from those departures or that every office filled its positions with recent graduates.
ProPublica’s review drew on records, bar information, social media and interviews. It found more than 50 recently hired assistant U.S. attorneys with fewer than three years of experience, including about 20 who had passed a bar exam in the preceding year. The newsroom said the total was probably an undercount because government personnel data redact employees’ identities. The department did not respond to ProPublica’s questions, the report said.
Those limits matter: the figures describe the newsroom’s documented cases, not a complete official account of the department’s hiring. They show that inexperienced lawyers have entered federal prosecutor roles under the changed rules, but they do not establish how many such hires there have been in total.
Why experience matters to the work
Justice Department postings describe assistant U.S. attorneys as handling investigations, gathering evidence and representing the United States at trial and on appeal. The postings say assignments become more complex as prosecutors gain training and experience. That description helps explain why a change in the experience threshold is consequential, but it does not determine whether a particular new attorney is qualified or how well that person will perform.
ProPublica compared the new hires with departing prosecutors and reported that many of those leaving had substantial experience. Former officials and legal experts raised concerns about possible effects on prosecution quality. Those are attributed assessments of potential risks, not evidence that the newer hires have mishandled cases or that the hiring change has already produced a measurable decline in legal work.
The distinction is important in assessing what the policy shift means. A lower formal experience threshold creates a route into federal prosecution for lawyers earlier in their careers. It does not, on the evidence available here, show that all new hires lack preparation, nor does it establish what training or supervision each office provides.
Caseload changes provide context, not proof of cause
ProPublica’s November 18 analysis of Federal Judicial Center data found that immigration-related prosecutions rose during Trump’s first 18 months, while drug prosecutions fell about 10% nationally. Fraud cases were flat nationwide, with declines in some districts. These figures describe changes in case mix over a defined period; they do not show that hiring less-experienced lawyers caused those changes.
In an earlier investigation, ProPublica reported that the Justice Department declined more than 23,000 criminal cases in the administration’s first six months while bringing substantially more immigration cases. The department disputed the interpretation, saying it had reviewed pending matters to clean and validate case-management data. That dispute is relevant to how the figures should be read, and the earlier analysis should not be treated as proof of the reason for any individual case decision.
Together, the reporting documents a revised hiring rule, examples of newly licensed attorneys entering prosecutor jobs, and shifting caseload figures. It also leaves key questions unresolved: ProPublica’s count is incomplete, and the evidence does not connect the hiring policy to a specific prosecution outcome.
