Oregon Officials Intervened to Save Twin After Newborn’s Death in Faith-Healing Sect

After Ginnifer Mitchell died following a 2017 home birth, police insisted her surviving twin receive hospital care. Her parents later pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide and criminal mistreatment.

When newborn Ginnifer Mitchell died after a home birth in Oregon City on March 5, 2017, authorities insisted that her surviving twin, Evelyn, be taken to a hospital. Marshall Phillips, then a member of the family’s faith-healing community, later became Evelyn’s guardian and left the group, according to ProPublica’s account of the case.

The case brought together an emergency intervention, a criminal prosecution and a state law limiting the use of spiritual treatment as a defense in certain child-neglect cases. The available records establish that officers required the family to take Evelyn for hospital care or said they would do so themselves. They do not identify the specific legal provision used to compel that immediate transport.

A home birth and an emergency decision

Ginnifer and Evelyn were born prematurely at home. The Oregonian reported in June 2017 that Ginnifer died from complications of prematurity, citing the medical examiner, and that investigators said hospital care could have prevented her death. The surviving twin was taken to hospital and received treatment.

Police involvement came as officials sought medical care for Evelyn after her sister’s death. ProPublica reports that officers told the family to take the newborn to hospital or they would transport her themselves. The Oregonian’s earlier account also describes police intervention and Evelyn’s hospital admission.

The episode illustrates the difference between a family’s religious beliefs and the state’s response when a child may need urgent medical attention. The sources support the fact of intervention, but not a more specific account of the legal authority officers relied on at the scene.

The criminal case and its outcome

Sarah and Travis Mitchell, Ginnifer and Evelyn’s parents, initially faced charges described in contemporaneous coverage as murder in connection with the newborn’s death. The final outcome was different: in July 2018, the Clackamas County District Attorney’s Office said the couple pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide and criminal mistreatment.

The parents agreed to serve 80 months in prison, according to the prosecutor’s release. In a written statement included in that release, they said they should have sought adequate care for their children. The distinction between the initial charges and the guilty pleas matters: the documented conviction was for criminally negligent homicide, not murder.

The medical examiner’s conclusion, as reported by the Oregonian, linked Ginnifer’s death to complications of prematurity and stated that hospital care could have prevented it. That finding formed part of the public account of the case, while the parents’ plea and sentence are recorded in the district attorney’s official announcement.

What Oregon’s law says

Oregon changed state law in 1999 to remove a spiritual-treatment defense in a specified child-neglect manslaughter provision. The session law also amended other statutes. Its scope is defined by the criminal provisions it addresses; it should not be described as a blanket ban on faith healing or as a restriction on adults refusing medical care for themselves.

That legal history provides context for the state’s role in cases involving children whose caregivers rely on spiritual treatment. But the law’s existence alone does not establish which provision, if any, officials invoked when they pressed the Mitchell family to take Evelyn to hospital in 2017. The supplied reporting does not resolve that question.

ProPublica’s reporting draws on police, medical, court and legislative records, interviews and the reporter’s observations. A separate Oregonian report from 2017 independently corroborated key details of the death, the surviving twin’s treatment and police intervention.

Evelyn’s guardianship

Phillips, who was part of the sect at the time, later became Evelyn’s guardian and left the group, ProPublica reports. His role placed a former member of the community at the center of the surviving child’s care after the emergency and criminal case.

ProPublica also reports that the Mitchells filed a motion in October 2026 seeking to end the Phillipses’ permanent guardianship, then withdrew it in November. The publication says they are now seeking expanded visitation. The supplied research did not locate an independent court record or separate report confirming the motion’s status, and there is no evidence here that the guardianship has changed.

The case’s documented milestones are clear: Ginnifer died after the 2017 home birth, Evelyn survived after being taken to hospital, and her parents later pleaded guilty and received an 80-month prison term. Details of the current family court dispute remain based on ProPublica’s reporting and should be treated as attributed claims.

The Beacon Briefing

Stay informed. See further.

The stories that matter, the context behind them. Get Beacon’s essential reporting in your inbox.

Placeholder signup form · Connect your newsletter provider to activate.