German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius called it “quite a stupid thing” to criticize Ukraine for striking strategic military or military-used targets, pushing back against US concerns about Kyiv’s deep attacks inside Russia. The exchange took place on November 17 at a meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels.
The dispute centered on which Ukrainian operations allies should prioritize supporting. US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby argued that deep strikes had not helped end the war or slowed Russian advances at the front. Pistorius said criticism should instead focus on Russia’s attacks on Ukrainian energy, water and heating infrastructure.
Disagreement over priorities
Colby said Ukraine should receive support for its front-line needs and for associated mid-range strikes. He also warned that attacks on civilian infrastructure, including the Russian retailer Wildberries, could strengthen Russian public resolve and increase the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate. Those comments were his assessment of the strikes’ consequences, not independently established findings.
Pistorius’s objection was narrower than a defense of every Ukrainian operation inside Russia. He was responding to criticism of attacks on strategic military or military-used targets. The distinction matters because the reporting identifies a dispute over both the choice of targets and the military value of deep strikes.
There is also a disagreement over Wildberries. Ukraine says goods sold by the company include equipment and components used by Russia’s military; the company denies that claim. The available reporting does not independently resolve the dispute.
British Defence Secretary Wes Streeting also defended Ukraine’s strikes. He said they had degraded Russia’s war effort and “bought time and saved lives.” Like Colby’s criticism, Streeting’s statement is an official assessment of the strikes’ effects rather than an independently verified conclusion in the supplied evidence.
A debate at an arms-support meeting
The Ukraine Defence Contact Group meeting was convened to coordinate arms and ammunition support for Kyiv. NATO’s event schedule lists the November 17 gathering in Brussels and identifies Pistorius, Streeting, Colby and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy among the public opening participants.
Colby said Ukraine should not have to fight “with its hands tied,” while making the case that allies should focus support on front-line equipment and selected mid-range operations. The disagreement was therefore about how Ukraine should wage the war and what forms of military support are most useful, rather than a stated denial of Ukraine’s right to defend itself.
Reporting on the exchange describes Ukraine as having used drones to strike oil facilities and other sites deep inside Russia. But the supplied material does not establish the overall strategic effect of those attacks. It records competing arguments from US, German and British officials about whether the operations weaken Russia, help protect Ukraine or risk further escalation.
What the remarks do and do not establish
The headline characterization of the dispute as Germany criticizing the US compresses Pistorius’s remarks into a national position. The evidence establishes what the German defence minister said, but does not establish that his comment was a formal statement by the German government as a whole.
Nor do the available accounts independently test the officials’ claims about whether deep strikes have changed battlefield conditions, affected Russian public opinion or saved lives. The remarks establish a disagreement among allies over the aims and consequences of the attacks, but not a settled measure of their impact.
