Viral sweater comparison highlights differences in men’s and women’s knitwear

A fashion creator’s comparison of two $95 Abercrombie sweaters prompted questions about fibre content, while limited retail data shows differences across some brands and product ranges.

A comparison of two $95 Abercrombie & Fitch sweaters has drawn attention to a difference in their listed fibre content: the men’s style was described as 100% merino wool, while the women’s contained 30% wool. Fashion creator Rachael Brownfield highlighted the products in a video, according to The Guardian. The garments were different styles, so the comparison does not show that women were charged more for an equivalent sweater.

What the comparison shows

The women’s sweater was described in a separate Style Analytics account as 66% nylon, 30% merino and 4% elastane. That account and The Guardian agree on the 30% wool share, but the precise composition should be checked against the original product listing or garment label. The available reporting does not establish the dates when the two items were listed or whether their prices and compositions were unchanged over time.

The comparison raises a concrete question for shoppers: what do fibre labels reveal when garments in men’s and women’s ranges carry the same price? In this instance, the listed price was $95 for both items, but the garments differed in style and material composition. The evidence therefore supports a comparison of those two listings, not a conclusion that women paid more for the same product.

A limited snapshot across six brands

Style Analytics examined full-price sweater listings under $100 from Zara, COS, Abercrombie & Fitch, American Eagle, Uniqlo and H&M during the week of 25 to 31 October 2026. It reported that men’s sweaters in its sample were more likely to be made entirely from wool, cotton or cashmere, while women’s sweaters were twice as likely to contain polyester.

A separate report attributed to the same analysis put the difference in entirely natural-fibre sweaters at 46% for men’s products and 17% for women’s. It reported polyester in 30% of men’s items and 59% of women’s items. Those figures describe the particular listings and price band examined, not all clothing sold by the brands or the wider apparel market.

The pattern was not uniform across the brands. Style Analytics said its data showed no comparable natural-fibre proportion gap at Uniqlo or COS. It also noted that differences varied by brand and that some women’s ranges were larger. The findings are a snapshot of listings collected over one week, and the evidence does not establish that gender alone caused the differences in fibre mixes.

What the Abercrombie range audit adds

A separate review by Toxome said it catalogued 77 Abercrombie US sweater styles on 3 November 2026. In that audit, four of 29 men’s styles were listed as 100% merino, while none of 48 women’s styles was listed as 100% wool. Toxome said women’s styles containing wool were 30% wool or less.

That audit broadens the comparison beyond the two sweaters in Brownfield’s video, but it remains one outlet’s inventory review rather than a company disclosure or independently replicated study. Another report, published in October, said its own check found at least three women’s 100% wool sweaters. The differing results show why the date and scope of a product search matter: stock and the range of listings examined can affect the picture.

Possible explanations remain unproven

Style Analytics offered range size, design features and changing trends as possible explanations for the fibre differences, while stating that these were hypotheses. The reviewed evidence does not show why individual brands selected particular materials or demonstrate that a gender-based pricing practice produced the observed pattern.

The central finding is narrower: the reported products and selected retail listings show differences in fibre composition between some men’s and women’s sweaters, but the evidence is not enough to establish an industry-wide rule or a “pink tax.” Abercrombie had been approached for comment, according to The Guardian; the supplied reporting does not include a company response.

The Beacon Briefing

Stay informed. See further.

The stories that matter, the context behind them. Get Beacon’s essential reporting in your inbox.

Placeholder signup form · Connect your newsletter provider to activate.